Clark changed the direction of the Chorus from "standing on risers and singing" to fully staged, fully costumed musical revues, and decreased the politically themed content in favor of more general entertainment in a successful effort to attract a larger audience, including the non-gay community.

"[4] A major turning point came in May 1995, when the CGMC brought its successful musical revue, "Victory Canteen", to the Shubert Theater.

The revue, a salute to the United States armed forces during World War II, had been performed seven times at the Educational Center for the Arts, a much smaller theater in New Haven.

The CGMC also performs at many fundraisers for other nonprofit groups, and at local events such as the Molson Summertime Street Festival in New Haven in 1992 and the Hartford gay pride march for several years.

Since 2002, the main fundraiser for the chorus has been "Bingomania", a monthly bingo game with entertainment, hosted by "Joan Crawford", a man dressed up as the famous movie star.

In 2004 the Chorus merited a full page in the book How the Homosexuals Saved Civilization by Cathy Crimmins,[6] as an example of "how gay-tolerant small towns in Connecticut have become.

"{Page 52} In April 2013 three sold-out performances took place at Lyric Hall, a small, restored turn-of-the-20th-century theater in the historic Westville section of New Haven.

April 2015 saw the CGMC perform the New England premiere of "I Am Harvey Milk", an oratorio with words and music by Andrew Lippa.