The lyrics are about an African American concerned with his appearance including his skin color and hair type while not being accepted by a woman.
Songsheet cover for the music include caricatured African American faces and a photograph of minstrel performers of the song inset.
[5] The Library of Congress has a photograph of two Caucasian children pointing at an African American described as illustrating a line from the song.
[10] In 1945, William Howland Kenney gave a partial defense of Arthur Collins singing the lyrics of the song and described it as bathetic.
[11] Charles Kenyon incorporated a Caucasian woman struggling to perform the song in the 1929 movie Show Boat.