During its 10-year run, Boomer and Carton became the most listened to show in WFAN history, placing first among men ages 25–54.

Four months after his release from prison in 2020, he was rehired by WFAN, for which he hosted the number-one rated afternoon-drive program with Evan Roberts.

Carton became only the second broadcaster to ever host the number-one show in both morning and afternoon drive, after Howard Stern.

Carton also hosts a podcast and public service show called Hello, My Name Is Craig dedicated to helping listeners with gambling addiction and other issues.

[4] Carton's first book, Loudmouth: Tales (and Fantasies) of Sports, Sex, and Salvation from Behind the Microphone, was released on June 4, 2013.

[7] On WIP, Carton was a brash weekend host nicknamed "The Kid" and filled in on the station's morning-drive show.

In late 2000, Carton replaced Scott Kaplan on WNEW-FM's Sports Guys morning radio program in New York City, a job that he held for one year.

The Boomer and Carton show reached number one (men 25–54) in the Arbitron ratings within a year, a ranking that Imus had not achieved since 1993.

[citation needed] Carton and Esiason announced a 2013 NBA game between the Brooklyn Nets and the Washington Wizards.

[13][14][15] Trial testimony further proved that Carton had no existing gambling debt at the time when the alleged fraud was perpetrated.

[22] He reported to the United States Penitentiary, Lewisburg minimum-security satellite camp on June 17, 2019, to begin serving a minimum of 36 months of a maximum 42-month sentence.

[25] On December 10, 2020, it was also announced that Carton would host a weekly program airing Saturday mornings beginning January 9 called Hello, My Name Is Craig on which he would discuss problem gambling.