Michael Cusanelli of AllMusic writes "Dancin' With Them That Brung Me is one of those independent gems that the listener must find.

"[2] Ellen Rawson of FemMusic states that "Earle’s first album, Simple Gearle, received adulation and earned her fans.

Dancin’ with Them That Brung Me doesn't show a single sign of a sophomore slump.

"[3] Alex Steininger of InMusicWeTrust writes, "Toe-tappin', emotional country with plenty of feeling and love.

"[4] Steven Stone of EnjoyTheMusic says, "If Stacey Earle were a painter her work would look like Grandma Moses.