[4] In round 10, Nofoaluma made his NRL debut for the Tigers against the South Sydney Rabbitohs on the wing in the 54–10 loss at ANZ Stadium.

[5][6] The next week against the North Queensland Cowboys at Leichhardt Oval, Nofoaluma scored a match-winning try as the Tigers prevailed 22–20.

Leaping for a Benji Marshall cross-field bomb, Nofoaluma caught the ball before being shoved by Manly winger Jorge Tafua.

With most of his body in the air over the dead-in-goal line, Nofoaluma managed to place the ball down for what was described as, "arguably the most acrobatic try of the past decade.

[15] In April, he was named in the Samoan team to play against Fiji in the 2014 Pacific Rugby League International to qualify for the 2014 Four Nations.

[16] In Round 18, Nofoaluma suffered a season ending anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) knee injury.

After undergoing off-season surgery on his knee, Nofoaluma returned from the injury via the Wests Tigers NSW Cup side.

[24] Missing just one game for Wests Tigers, he was the team's joint leader for tries scored, with a career-best 14 and led the entire competition with 134 tackle breaks.

"[29] Nofoaluma finished the regular season in the NRL's top five performers for metres gained, tackle-breaks and offloads.

"[33] With Tuimoala Lolohea suffering a knee injury, Thompson moved to fullback and Nofoaluma returned his regular spot in the team for round 2.

Nofoaluma suffered a shoulder injury in the preseason and didn't make an appearance in first grade until round 11.

[36] Nofoaluma scored two tries for Wests in round 1 of the 2020 NRL season as the club defeated St. George Illawarra 24–14 at WIN Stadium.

[39] In round 17, he scored a hat-trick as Wests defeated Manly-Warringah 34-32 at Brookvale Oval,[40] taking him three clear on the NRL's leading try-scorer list for the season.

With the departure of Benji Marshall at the end of 2020, Nofoaluma entered the season as Wests Tigers' long serving player.

[44] In round 18 against Brisbane, he scored his 85th and 86th try for the Wests Tigers, becoming their all-time leading try scorer, surpassing the record of 84 held by Marshall and Chris Lawrence.

[54] Nofoaluma played a total of 17 games for the Wests Tigers in the 2023 NRL season as the club finished with the Wooden Spoon for a second straight year.

[58] On 20 June, it was reported that he had left Salford after just two appearances and returned to Australia to sign for Glebe in the Ron Massey Cup where he won the Grand Final defeating Wentworthville 19-12 scoring two tries to seal the game and receiving man of the match.

[61] At the end of 2016, Nofoaluma made his international debut for Samoa, playing fullback in an historic test match against Fiji in Apia.

[62] In June 2022, Nofoaluma played his third match for Samoa, scoring four tries against the Cook Islands in a comfortable victory at his "home ground" of Campbelltown Stadium.