The producers she chose to work with to make the music for this album was her husband, Jacob Lee Sooter, and four others, Jason Ingram, Seth Mosley, Paul Mabury, and Mike X.

[1][2][3][4] Awarding the album four and a half stars from CCM Magazine, Matt Conner states, "While already a successful recording artist, Andrews has yet to breakthrough to true stardom, but Deeper might do the trick.

"[6] Jeremy Armstrong, giving the album four stars at Worship Leader, writes, "Ultimately, Deeper is a reminder of his promise to complete the work he began in those who love him.

"[11] Allotting the album four and a half stars at The Christian Beat, Madeleine Dittmer responds, "The songs on Deeper shine brightly, while addressing the darkness we find within and around us, and offer an invitation to push for the hope of a new day.

"[9] Bersain Beristain, signaling in a three star review at Jesus Freak Hideout, cautions, "Though Deeper may be polished to a near perfect degree in production and performance, I still find it lacking greatly in originality as far as the actual content is concerned.