Reviewer Richard Lanoie of The Serious Comedy Site said that Sheen "more than proves there are still some great, original, and intelligently dark comics out there.

"[3] Daniel Berkowitz of website The Spit Take called Sheen "a hilarious and gifted performer" with "a unique voice that he’s able to expertly harness.

"[4] Drew Hunt of the Chicago Reader noted that Sheen's comedy can be "highly personal or emotionally transparent" and compared him to Brian Posehn for his "delivery and lucid, streetwise worldview.

[15] His debut album Holy Drivel was recorded by producer Matt Bayles of Minus the Bear.

[16] Chris Spector of Midwest Record praised Sheen's "high energy attack that doesn't run out of steam.