PopMatters called the album "yet another extraordinary piece of work that raises the proverbial bar once again ... this isn't just experimental; it's genuinely catchy.

"[1] The Village Voice wrote: "Diotima is the kind of album that requires multiple listens, possibly alternating between headphones and speakers, to absorb.

"[7] The editors of AllMusic awarded the album a full 5 stars, and Phil Freeman called it "the group's best work to date."

They're taking what they like from the genre and amplifying its power by adding elements from prog rock and minimalism, then stretching the songs to extraordinary length... in order to push the listener toward cathartic transcendence.

"[4] Pitchfork's Grayson Haver Currin commented: "Unapologetically extreme and intense, it's the most relentless album from a hyper-dexterous band that's never been one to take it easy... Diotima forgoes the long-short-long tack of previous Krallice efforts, creating marathons out of marathons that demand complete attention and destroy attention spans.