[10] The album opens with the lead single "Come On Over", which was co-written by country music artist Rachel Proctor, Victoria Banks and Simpson herself.

[12] The seventh track "Still Don't Stop Me" is a ballad in the key of E major about a love gone bad, driven by acoustic guitar and percussion.

[13] "When I Loved You Like That", the eighth track, is an up-tempo song in the key of A♭ major backed by electric and steel guitars and percussion.

[16] The Dallas Morning News called the first single "Come on Over" a "terrific slice of sultry pop-country", but described the rest of the album as "totally listless".

"[28] The Los Angeles Times said "Her struggle is most striking on the title track, written by Dolly Parton, who shows up to harmonize with Simpson...

"[25] Allmusic found her performance "unfailingly listless no matter how many theatrical gestures she attempts to cram in her big boring ballad.

[24] Las Vegas Weekly found the album to be filled with "tiresome ballads" performed with "no tooth, no gut, just monotony and palpable disinterest.

"[30] In a more positive review, the New York Post said that "she's created an album where she consistently shows off her full-bodied voice with solid, yet simple tunes that don't overthink the music.

"[22] Country Weekly magazine's Chris Neal said that although Simpson seemed to be "trying a little too hard" on some songs, the album was "solid pop-country fare with a lyrical emphasis on sensuality and self-esteem.