Metatron (Curtis Armstrong) is looking for food on a dumpster when he is suddenly transported to a bar where he finds prophet Chuck Shurley (Rob Benedict).
Over the course of their conversation, He also mentions He likes the Winchesters and constantly brought back Castiel for them, but He is done helping them since their quest to destroy the Mark caused Amara to be released upon the world.
Sam discovers that the murderer had black veins on his lower arms, recalling the insanity virus Amara spread shortly after her release.
Deputy Jan Harris (Sonja Bennett) is exposed to a strange fog and contracts the same virus, causing her to murder her husband.
The fog then reappears and begins to cover the entire town, causing Sam, Dean, the Sheriff and many townspeople to hide in the police station.
The former angel is disgusted by God's apathy towards Amara, and tells Him that He's become a coward and that the humans are His greatest creations, because although they have many bad qualities, they never give up.
God meanwhile writes the final part of His autobiography, and afterwards, while an apparently moved Metatron is reading it, grabs a guitar and starts singing “Dink's Song”.
"[4] Sean McKenna from TV Fanatic, gave a 4.8 star rating out of 5, stating: "How awesome was it to see Sam, Dean and Chuck reunited once again, with the brothers realizing who their friend actually was before the 'We should probably talk' line?
"[5] Bridget LaMonica from Den of Geek, gave a perfect 5 star rating out of 5, stating: "The episode was loaded with hilarious one liners and quips from many characters, but Chuck stole the show in the first half.
"[7] MaryAnn Sleasman of TV.com wrote, "After plodding through weeks of filler, 'Don't Call Me Shurley' was the kind of major turn that Supernatural's central story needed as we enter Season 11's final episodes.
It gave us the momentum to move forward (finally) while simultaneously grabbing onto the bits and pieces of past that have fallen to the side, been lost in the Impala's well-worn seats, and forgotten in Sam Winchester's massive pockets like a certain amulet that's been missing since that time Dean and Sam died and went to heaven and realized it sucked.