[2] Following his release from Real Salt Lake, Toia joined FC Tucson in the USL Premier Development League where he made 15 appearances for the club during the 2012 season.
[4] In February 2013, Toia signed with USL Pro club Phoenix FC for the inaugural season.
[5] He made his professional debut on March 23 in the club's inaugural match, a 2–0 loss to Los Angeles Blues.
Toia finished the season with 6 goals to lead the team and was a nominee for USL Pro Rookie of the Year.
[7] After Chivas folded in November 2014, Toia was selected in the 2014 MLS Dispersal Draft by the Montreal Impact.