In September 1921, Campbell joined Philadelphia Field Club from Babcock & Wilcox.
Campbell remained with the reconstituted Bethlehem Steel for one season, then transferred to the Fall River F.C.
In the 1927 National Challenge Cup, Campbell scored once in Fall River's 7-0 romp over Holley Carburetor F.C.
In 1928, he moved to the New York Giants, but played only four games before the team was suspended by the ASL at the start of the "Soccer Wars".
Following his retirement from playing, he worked in a variety of occupations, including as a builder, a fisherman and an owner of "a cranberry bog in West Creek, New Jersey".