In July, Caylor was selected to compete at the 2022 Pan American Championships alongside Zoey Molomo, Tiana Sumanasekera and Alicia Zhou.

[1][2] In August, she then competed at the 2022 U.S. National Gymnastics Championships, where she won bronze on floor and placed fourth in the all-around, fifth on uneven bars, and eighth on vault.

[3] Caylor made her senior debut at the 2023 Winter Cup, where she placed seventh on uneven bars.

[4] In August she competed at the 2023 U.S. Classic and placed twelfth on floor and sixteenth on uneven bars and balance beam.

[6][7] In February, Caylor competed at the 2024 Winter Cup and placed fifth in the all-around, seventh on uneven bars and eighth on balance beam.