[2] Nemeth attended Notre Dame High School[3] in Lawrence Township, New Jersey, where he graduated in 2001.

[1] Nemeth attended Sacred Heart University upon his high school graduation, continuing his football career.

[5] Nemeth re-enrolled in college in 2010 at Towson University, but dropped out due to financial restrictions.

[5] In 2015, Nemeth signed with the York Capitals of American Indoor Football.

[8][9][10] In July 2015, he was named the head wrestling coach at Notre Dame High School.