"Each Time" became the band's final top-10 hit in the United Kingdom, debuting and peaking at number two on the UK Singles Chart.

It was their final chart hit in most other countries, including Germany, Ireland, New Zealand, Sweden, and Switzerland.

[4] The song diverts from the band's established pop sound in favor of an R&B style in the vein of Stevie Wonder's music from the 1970s.

[5] In Oxfordshire, Fox FM head of music Stuart Davies also agreed that the band's new style suited them well and called the song "excellent".

[6][7] In November 2021, the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) awarded the song a silver certification for sales and streams exceeding 200,000 units.