Shortly after, guitarist Josh Branas was added and the quintet toured regionally until 2005, when Carroll and Hough left the band.
[5] In August 2008, Branas decided to leave the band, with guitarist Jordan Tomb taking his place.
The April 5 concert had the same line-up, but with the surprise addition of the former guitarist Carroll and the former drummer Hough appearing on "How to Build a Sandcastle".
[citation needed] Due to Capolupo's commitment to The Devil Wears Prada, the band has been on hold.
In 2022 the band announced a "Party Time" reunion show being held at Penn Brewery on Jan 28, featuring opening acts Greywalker, Windchimes, and Casketmaker.