Shortly after, guitarist Josh Branas was added and the quintet toured regionally until 2005, when Carroll and Hough left the band.
After several failed tours, bass guitarist Lucarelli and drummer Capolupo decided to leave the band.
The April 5 concert had the same line-up, but with the surprise addition of the former guitarist Carroll and the former drummer Hough appearing on "How to Build a Sandcastle".
[citation needed] Due to Capolupo's commitment to The Devil Wears Prada, the band has been on hold.
In 2022 the band announced a "Party Time" reunion show being held at Penn Brewery on Jan 28, featuring opening acts Greywalker, Windchimes, and Casketmaker.