The album showcases Reminisce's versatility with tracks such as "Ori", which incorporates traditional Yoruba music, and "Where I Come From", which draws from autobiographical narratives similar to those found in Jay-Z's "Where I'm From".

[5] Joey Akan of Pulse Nigeria described El-Hadj as a deeply personal and grounded album that blends reflection and celebration, showcasing Reminisce’s growth and versatility.

Praising its introspective storytelling and vibrant party tracks, he concluded, “It’s a pilgrimage of some sort for the rapper, as he connects to a deeper level of narration and vulnerability to recreate his Mecca."

[7] Chiagoziem Onyekwena of Filterfree noted that the album showcased the rapper's ability to blend introspection with a variety of sounds and themes, bridging eras and genres effortlessly.

While not all the tracks wowed him, he praised moments like "I Remember" for humanizing Reminisce and commending its depth and honesty, and "Ibadi", calling it “the perfect Nigerian strip club anthem”.