LaBrie hired new musicians, including guitarist Marco Sfogli from Italy and Richard Chycki as sound engineer.

[2] LaBrie explains that Elements of Persuasion represents the various factors that guide us throughout our lives and how, at different stages, certain things become significantly more important than others.

[3] LaBrie cites several bands as influences for Elements of Persuasion, including Mudvayne, Meshuggah, Linkin Park, and Sevendust.

"[3] The direct influences of these bands can be heard in songs like "Lost," which features a jazz-fusion vibe, and "Smashed," which incorporates a piano melody inspired by Bruce Hornsby.

Indirect influences include literature that LaBrie reads, social issues, personal observations, and the dynamics within relationships.