Food & Wine listed it as one of 19 best vegetarian and vegan restaurants in the US.

[10] The Washington Post called it "an upscale vegan dinner party.

"[3] Washington Life magazine called the vegan tasting menu a masterpiece.

[2] Food Network named them one of the top 20 vegan restaurants in the United States.

[11] In 2024, then-Washington Wizards offensive coach Joseph Blair said Elizabeth's was one of his favorite Washington, D.C. area restaurants.