Since 2006, the congregation has been located at the Cornerstone Center, 178 Bennett Avenue in Manhattan, New York City.

This structure was later described as a "cattle shed" and replaced with a new stone edifice known as Trinity Church that was dedicated on June 29, 1729.

[2] German-speaking members seceded from the congregation in 1750 and purchased a brewery on Cliff Street that became Christ Church Lutheran.

Shortly thereafter, the building was resold at the same price to the United German Lutheran Churches and the result was referred to as "Christ and Old Trinity".

[2] Other congregations that branched from St. Matthew's around this time include: In 1852, the United Lutheran Churches of New York celebrated their 100th Anniversary.

[2] In 1903, St. Matthew's built a brick and stone church and a three-story residence for $25,000 at 300 West 9th Avenue[clarification needed] at 44th Street to designs by architect John Boese of 280 Broadway.

[2] Nearby at 145th Street and Convent Avenue, the church built a four-story brick and stone parish house in 1908 at a cost of $50,000 to designs by architect John Boese.