Tracks on Evenifudontbelieve were initially planned for an EP release, but Whyte felt that "there was so much with a similar vibe that it turned into an album pretty naturally.

"[3] Whyte found that some of these tracks were getting good reactions in live settings and decided to skip an EP and organise the music into album length.

[3] Fact described the album as containing "squealing prog guitar over huge rising synths, turbo trance riffs over even quicker trap drums" as well as happy hardcore.

[6] The NME gave the album a four out of five rating, describing the album as "a perfect example of his blink-and-you'll-miss-it, magpie's eye gift for reassembling modern dance music styles in his own image" and that "The record may be more enjoyable than its predecessor, but it sometimes feels like the Rustie of 2011 has just been wheeled back out for another spin.

"[1] Fact placed the album at 11th place on their list of top albums of 2015, stating that Whyte "drills his agenda down to the things that make him tick: happy hardcore and trance, dolphins and pills, Coral Castlez and Big Catzz.