[1] It follows 14-year-old Emma Alonso, who moves to Miami, Florida, with her father and discovers she is the most powerful witch of her generation.

[citation needed] Emily Ashby of Common Sense Media gave Every Witch Way 2 stars, stating that the show "devotes too much time and energy to Maddie's superficiality and spite," making it an unsuitable choice for an impressionable age group.

She criticized that "none of Maddie's actions ever land her in hot water she can't work a spell to escape," so viewers never see her learn a lesson.

Ashby also noted that the show "suffers from subpar acting and a low-budget look and feel," and that the lack of a laugh track makes it "unusually flat for a tween sitcom."

She added that the absence of engaging elements leaves "nothing to distract [viewers] from the excessive superficiality and pettiness" of many of the central characters.