The website was accompanied by a fictional short story (purporting to be true) written by an anonymous person under the pen name "James Richards" (a pseudonym drawn from the legal first names of Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr, the two surviving Beatles, who were born James Paul McCartney and Richard Starkey respectively).

In the story, Richards describes driving through the Del Puerto Canyon road in California, when he had to pull over to let his dog use the restroom.

The first photograph (which appears on the main page of the website) includes the cassette's case, with the album title & track list being written on ruled paper.

Despite the criticism of Richards' story, Everyday Chemistry has been met with praise for its mixing, production and mashup choices.

[7] "Four Guys" "Talking to Myself" "Anybody Else" "Sick to Death" "Jenn" "I'm Just Sitting Here" "Soldier Boy" "Over the Ocean" "Days Like These" "Saturday Night" "Mr. Gator's Swamp Jamboree"