Monty Arnold, reviewing for Playbill, added, "The other three, besides Scott, are a younger actor who has an extended YouTube sequence and two women who serve as backup singers — 'The Mennonettes' — and share other scenes with her.

It starred Sherie Rene Scott with direction by Michael Mayer, choreography by Michele Lynch, and orchestrations and arrangements by Tom Kitt.

[5] Scott presented an earlier form of the show titled You May Now Worship Me on March 31, 2008, as a one-night benefit for the Phyllis Newman Women's Health Initiative of The Actors’ Fund.

(It was a last-minute replacement for The Roundabout Theatre Company's planned production of Terrence McNally's Lips Together, Teeth Apart, which was canceled when Megan Mullally withdrew after differences with director Joe Mantello.)

[11][12] Ben Brantley's review in The New York Times of the 2009 off-Broadway production stated that "it easily qualifies as one of the year’s most extravagantly entertaining new musicals.