The EP is an emo release, consisting of four tracks with a mixture of twee pop vocals by Hannah Vogan and Chris Sheppard.

[2] Buford asked Hannah Vogan to join the band, primarily because she had been taking opera lessons, and she accepted.

Everyone Asked About You's EP initially did not see any mainstream recognition, with it only being predominantly within local circles which was a characteristic shared by numerous punk bands at the time.

Reviewer Dylan Ostendorf wrote that it was too "cutesy" and their lyrics and usage of a Moog synthesizer made him "queasy".

[2][4] He later said that the hand depended on basic rock rhythms, but the band had similarities with Rainer Maria and some parts of the EP were decent.

Maximum Rocknroll in 2000 called the EP "smooth and pleasing" with their emo pop style in a passing mention on a column.