It picks up when Phoebe's brother, Jayden decides to run for office in New York City.
Phoebe swears that it was a just a one time thing but is upset with Jayden because she feels like he is slut shaming her for her carefree approach to sexual hookups.
The siblings make up as the show continues to center on Jayden's political run for office, Phoebe's attempts to cease attraction for Hamilton, and her work-life balance with her podcast role at the company Parakeet.
On February 25, 2021, Freeform gave Everything's Trash But It's Okay a pilot order with Phoebe Robinson as the star and writer.
[17] Upon the title change announcement, Jordan Carlos, Toccarra Cash, Nneka Okafor and Moses Storm were cast to star.