[4] In an interview with 10 Magazine, Claudette said "My intention with Everything Was Green was simply to share my personal cycle of observation.

[6] Veniana Vucago from Acclaim Magazine said "Everything Was Green lends lush, spine-tingling walls of synths accompanied by melodic falsettos.

The R&B up-and-comer showcases his lyrical talent, skillfully intertwining personal experiences and emotions that bleed onto each track.

"[7] Ayodeji Ibrahim Lateef from Yours Truly called the EP "a mesmerizing blend of soul, hip-hop, and pop that showcases their musical versatility and creative prowess.".

[4] Sydney Scott from Music Daily said "This six song EP takes listeners on a deeply introspective personal journey through Forest Claudette's experiences and emotions.