[2] Matthew Brown, who was President of Washington Academy at the time, was the first pastor.

[3] As Washington progressed beyond the pioneer stage, the townsfolk began to partake in more leisurely activities, including the playing of cards and attending dances.

[3] A second building, in the Greek Revival Architecture style, was built in 1851.

[2] James I. Brownson, who also served as President Pro Tempore of Washington & Jefferson College, was pastor for over 50 years.

[4] The church operates the Matthew Brown Fellowship, a faith-based program that selects several Washington & Jefferson College students with local charitable organizations.