The song was written by Ben Burgess, Ernest and Mark Holman, and produced by Joey Moi.

[1] In late December 2021, Wallen posted a teaser photo on Instagram of he and Ernest sitting on stools and holding guitars, captioning it "Flower Shops open at Midnight tonight".

It has a "shuffle" tempo of approximately 44 beats per minute, and the verses are mainly based around the chord pattern G-Am-D/F♯-D7.

[4] Chris Parton of Sounds Like Nashville commented that the song "[is] a clever, throwback duet" and "a classic done-her-wrong apology anthem".

[5] On February 14, 2022, Ernest and Wallen released the song's acoustic version.