Lynsey Hipgrave from BBC Radio 5 Live's Danny Baker Show and BT Sport replaced Cates the following season.
A number of commentators were used for the programme, the main one being Paul Walker, who produces commentary for the Pitch International World Feed, who also worked for the BBC on The Football League Show.
Channel 5 also used Sky Sports commentators for their match highlight coverage such as Bill Leslie, Daniel Mann and Gary Weaver.
Other pundits that appeared on the show were Michael Gray, Mark Bright, Gus Poyet, Alex McLeish, Jamie Cureton, Clinton Morrison, Chris Iwelumo and Karl Robinson.
On 22 July 2017, it was reported that break clauses had been activated in Riley and Hipgrave's contracts and they would be replaced by Colin Murray for the 2017–18 season.