The only year for which NEL standings exist are 1908-1909 when Fore River finished fourth.
In 1915, the team won the Massachusetts State Cup with a victory over Lynne Fosse F.C.
In 1915, Fore River entered the Southern New England Soccer League (SNESL).
In 1918, the league suspended operations as a result of the loss of players to military service in World War I. Fore River then moved to the Boston League for the 1918-1919 season.
Fore River returned to the SNESL in 1919, but there are no records for this season.