"[2] At New Release Tuesday, Kevin Davis highlighted that "Audrey puts her full passion behind everything she sings, and is an avid reader of Scripture and other faith-based influences, which makes her lyrics even more rooted in Truth.

"[3] Calvin Moore of The Christian Manifesto wrote that "One is so drawn in by the contemplative music and Assad's supple voice, that it is hard to realize you've been lulled into a place so impossibly deep that one can scarce escape it.

At Jesus Freak Hideout, Roger Gelwicks told that the album was "Captivating at its core and daring in its purpose", which it comes "with creative energy at full capacity", and because of that "Fortunate Fall carries the day.

"[2] At New Release Tuesday, Kevin Davis noted that "These are great songs to pray along with Audrey and express your own yearnings for holiness and God's presence.

"[3] Jonathan Andre of Indie Vision Music said that "Fortunate Fall is one of the highlights according to a vast unanimous majority (critics and listeners alike) as we witness a moment of tranquillity, solace, enjoyableness and poignancy delivered through these 11 tracks.

"[6] At Louder Than the Music, Jono Davies called it a "must-have album" if the listener wants songs that are "heart warming and soulful", which comes with "a warmth and genuine tone".