[2] They won the Sheffield & Hallamshire Senior Cup in 1973–74 and finished as Yorkshire League runners-up in 1974–75.
During the same 1976–77 season they made their FA Cup debut,[3] but lost to Winterton Rangers in the preliminary round at Silkstone Road.
After three seasons in the top division, the club left the NCEL to join the more local Sheffield & Hallamshire County Senior League (S&HCSL), entering at the S&HCSL's second tier, Division One.
In their first season in the S&HCSL's top flight, the club won the league title, an achievement they repeated two years later.
A new Frecheville Community Association was formed in 2019, but lasted only the duration of the shortened 2019–20 season before disbanding again.