The club was formed in 2000, joining the Premier Division of the Central Midlands League (CMFL).

After a third consecutive second-placed finish in 2005–06 (a season which also saw them win the League Cup again) they were promoted to Division One of the Northern Counties East League (NCEL).

In 2007–08 they reached the 3rd qualifying round in their debut FA Cup campaign, and won promotion to the NCEL Premier Division[3] after winning the Division One title.

After winning the League Cup in 2009–10, they were relegated back to Division One at the end of the 2010–11 season.

A series of images taken during the Dinnington Town vs. Sheffield Wednesday XI friendly match, 30 July 2008.