[2] From First To Last received mixed reviews from critics, and its change in sound alienated the band's fanbase.

Subsequently, despite being given a high profile marketing campaign by Suretone,[3] the album underperformed commercially, and only reached number 81 on the Billboard 200; as a result, the band split from the label the following year.

This release coincided with a Hot Topic in-store performance in Novi, Michigan on February 13.

The song information from "We All Turn Back to Dust" revealed that the album would have 11 tracks.

All tracks are written by Matt Good, Travis Richter and Derek Bloom, except where noted.