As of February 2018, the website had almost 50 million scanned newspaper pages.

He began running the website in 1999 with a collection of old postcards of Fulton.

In 2003, Tryniski purchased a microfilm scanner to expand his scanning project.

[2][3] As of December 2013, the site averaged six million page views per month.

The website has retained its URL and "Old Fulton Post Cards" name despite its much expanded scope.