[7] Ben Tipple of DIY called it "all fun without feeling frivolous, packing relatable substance into its genuinely jovial sound".

[4] Jamie MacMillan of Dork described the album as "a whirlwind journey through the world and mind of one of our brightest new indie pop stars, and Garageband Superstar delivers on all that potential and excitement (and then some)".

[11] Caleb Campbell of Under the Radar called it "a debut that bursts with personality and irrepressible energy", adding "it doesn't seem like Hibberd is aiming to be the next Avril Lavigne, or Weezer, or Green Day.

[9] In mixed reviews, Finley Holden of Clash called the album "a bold, contained statement nonetheless, doubling down on her niche style with a few twists and turns brings us some truly great moments to cherish".

[3] El Hunt of NME wrote: "when she steers away from pastiche and fully delves into cataloguing the mundanity, pomposity and sheer ridiculousness of grotty Little England, she's at her best as a songwriter".