It featured a collection of nearly 60,000 pop culture artifacts, including magazines, movie posters, toys, buttons, badges, cereal boxes, trading cards, dolls, figurines, and other memorabilia.

In 2011, Andy Hershberger was promoted to Associate Curator/Registrar, and has since worked with Melissa Geppi-Bowersox in the creation of a curatorial advisory committee.

Geppi's Entertainment Museum was host to a wide range of rotating exhibits on topics such as Star Wars, the Overstreet Comic Book Price Guide, and previews of upcoming toys.

In February 2013, the temporary exhibit was Milestones: African Americans in Comics, Pop Culture and Beyond.

Developed and curated by Michael Davis, co-founder of Milestone Media, it ran through March 2014.