[1] AllMusic's Mark Deming praised the album, calling it a "very special dose of rock and soul, and one of the most purely enjoyable debuts of 2016".

[4] Kris Needs of Record Collector wrote: "Haynes' mellifluous voice hits home throughout, particularly effective on slower burners such as 'Tide' and 'Keep Me', invoking a deeper hoodoo on 'Kingdom Come' and 'Don't Need It'".

[7] Kevin Irwin of The Line of Best Fit simply resumed: "the formula might not be a new one, and ultimately Seratones are unlikely to change the world, but they will make your day".

[8] Pete Feenstra of Classic Rock saw the album as a "tumble dryer full of retro ideas given a contemporary currency by their restless drive, which evades categorisation".

[5] In his mixed review for PopMatters, Dustin Ragucos wrote: "Get Gone might not show its strengths in its lyricism, but it makes up for that by being a talented culmination of energy".