The album's final song is a cover of Bad Religion's "We're Only Gonna Die".

[4] Trouser Press criticized the EP's title track as "a maddening novelty number in which [Tim] DeLaughter blurts the title over and over with barely a pause for breath.

"[3] Alternatively, Cashbox's Troy J. Augusto praised the EP as "fun filler", and believed that the release "shows further growth from this promising pop-punk quartet".

[5] Tripping Daisy were unhappy with Island's decision to release Get It On, citing its poor quality; Tim DeLaughter commented in 1998 that the band's performance at Trees "wasn't the best show to do [a live album] on".

[6] By September 1995, Get It On had sold 4,000 copies in the United States, according to Nielsen SoundScan.