Two years after the events of the first story, Silver has become the new Wild Man of the Woods, and Tobias has ended their romantic relationship.

One day, Henry receives a letter from his mother; she is investigating the disappearance of Maud Lindherst, who has been kidnapped by a vampire.

The fairy servant becomes the new Lord of Greenhollow Wood, allowing Silver to become mortal once again and to rekindle his relationship with Tobias.

While Henry Silver's actions are praised, Maud's similar pursuits are not considered to be socially desirable for a woman of her era.

[5] Publishers Weekly also gave a starred review to Drowned Country, praising the horror elements of Fairyland as well as the romance between Tobias and Silver.

[6] A review from Book Riot praised the way in which Drowned Country expands on the mythology of its predecessor, as well as the "strong ensemble of characters".