They reached the final the following season, beating Gresley Rovers 3–1 in a replay at Bramall Lane after the first match at Wembley had ended in a 4–4 draw.

They also reached the semi-finals of the FA Trophy, losing 2–1 on aggregate to Runcorn,[6] as well as becoming the first Division One team to win the league's President's Cup.

[2] They reached the first round of the FA Cup again in 1994–95 and lost 4–1 at home to Carlisle United in a match that was moved to Valley Parade in Bradford;[6] the attendance of 6,548 remains a club record.

[2] After a third-place finish in 1998–99, the club were relegated to Division One the following season, although they did reach the first round of the FA Cup again, losing 6–0 at Forest Green Rovers.

A ninth-place finish in 2003–04 was enough to earn a return to the Premier Division due to league restructuring caused by the creation of the Conference North and South.

In 2008–09 the club won the league's Challenge Cup and finished fourth in the Premier Division, qualifying for the promotion play-offs.

The next five seasons saw Guiseley qualify for the promotion play-offs on each occasion; in 2010–11 they defeated Boston United on penalties in the semi-finals after a 1–0 win in the home leg was cancelled out by losing 3–2 away, but were then beaten 3–2 by AFC Telford United in the final on 15 May;[7] they also reached the FA Cup first round again, losing 5–0 at home to Crawley Town.

[1] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.