Hartley-Smith made a single first-class appearance for Surrey against Gloucestershire at The Oval in 1880.
[1] Surrey won the toss and elected to bat first, making 114 all out, with Smith scoring 11 runs before he was dismissed by William Woof.
Gloucestershire were then dismissed for 84 in their first-innings, with Surrey then making 114 all out in their second-innings, during which Smith was run out for 6.
[2] He later made a second first-class appearance for Sussex against Kent in 1889 at the County Ground, Hove.
Forced to follow-on in their second-innings, Sussex made 123 all out, with Hartley-Smith the last man out, dismissed for a duck by Wright.