At the merge, the core alliance of five stayed together and successfully eliminated Baskauskas and his brother Vytas, as well as Tina Wesson, and Eastin's mother Laura Morett (for the second time).
With Bankston gone, Moss took control of the outsiders' alliance and finally convinced Eastin to vote with him and Collins against Monica Culpepper.
However, this resulted in a stalemate of two consecutive tied votes, which led to Collins' elimination after a rock draw.
With no one else left to turn to, Moss and Eastin tried to convince Culpepper to join them in eliminating Peterson as a final effort against Apostol, but she refused.
Moss was voted out at the Final Five, and after losing the Redemption Island duel, he became the fourteenth person eliminated from Survivor: Blood vs. Water, finished in sixth place, and became the fifth jury member.