[13] Philip Cosores of Consequence of Sound wrote that while the bands songs may sound like "instigators, getting people riled up for some masculine bro-down and canned beer chugging", but are rather "desperate and haunted, dealing with mental illness, instability, heartbreak, and the human condition in a very honest and direct manner, without being bogged down in self-pity".

Other highlights include "Psychic Trauma" and "No Thoughts", which they believed sounds influenced by Kurt Cobain, and Billie Joe Armstrong on "I'm Not Part of Me".

[14] Al Horner of NME believed that when compared to the bands previous album Attack on Memory, the record felt "tame and unimposing in comparison".

"[15] Pitchfork's Ian Cohen praised the record, saying that Baldi "is simply unwilling or unable to stop writing hook-filled songs, rendering Here and Nowhere Else even more tense and thrillingly conflicted than its predecessor.

On June 24, 2024, it was announced that in celebration of the tenth anniversary of the albums release, the album will be performed in full in venues across the United States, alongside a deluxe edition featuring a full live performance and two remixes of "Giving Into Seeing" and "I'm Not Part of Me".