Formed in 1865 and based at Top Field, Hitchin took part in the inaugural FA Cup competition in 1871–72.

Turning professional early in the twentieth century, financial worries were compounded by a fire at Top Field in 1911.

A brief one-season spell at The Cricket Ground, Hitchin followed, where it's believe they played their inaugural FA Cup fixture.

Hitchin's ground at Top Field acquired a proud grandstand during the late 19th century, although the players were still obliged to change at The Cricketers public house across the street.

They were founded as Hitchin Blue Cross Brigade in the late 1890s and were founder members of the Herts County League in 1898–99.