In 1912, the Hitters played as members of the Class D level Oklahoma State League before permanently folding during the season.
On June 21, 1912, both the Anadarko Indians and Oklahoma City Senators teams disbanded from the league.
The Hitters had a final record of 21–23, playing the season under managers Al Vorhees, Jim Bouldin and Johnny Hendley.
The final standings were led by Okmulgee Glassblowers (38–10) followed by the Tulsa Terriers (33–15), Anadarko Indians (24–23), Holdenville Hitters (21–23), McAlester Miners (21–25), Guthrie (15–33) and Oklahoma City Senators (15–33).
[8] The name of the home ballpark for the 1912 Holdenville Hitters is unknown, but the location is reported to have been a short distance from the center of the city.