While an amateur team for much of its existence, it played a single season in the professional National Association Football League.
After three seasons in the MAFL, Hollywood Inn moved to the National Association Football League.
The team finished second from the bottom of the standings and moved back the amateur leagues the next season.
Hollywood Inn finished a lowly eighth in the league standings for the 1911-1912 season, but made up for it when it went to the semifinals of the newly established American Amateur Football Association Cup.
The AAFA would soon evolve into the United States Football Association and gain entry into FIFA in 1913.