[8][10][15] The Line of Best Fit went as so far to compare Hologram Jams to 3OH!3,[14] while reviewers from Pitchfork, Spectrum Culture, and The Skinny reported feeling exhausted from the album's overwhelming amount of noise and upbeat energy.

Loud and Quiet criticized it for ranging "between white boy skit and whiny primetime talent show hopeful" instead of sounding like a "banshee call for something belligerent" in his past works.

[8] AllMusic suggested the synthesizers exaggerated Whitney's "dazzlingly shrill singing style and flare for dramatics" that turned off some reviewers of prior Jaguar Love releases.

"[7] Hologram Jams's more decent reviews appreciated it as a fun dance record,[5][7][15] NME's Kelly Murray particularly enjoying it as a satirical one.

[9] The change towards a more electronic sound was also positively commented on by a few reviewers,[9] including Erin Lyndal Martin of PopMatters, who claimed it still had "the sheer energy the music puts forth and the exuberant elastics of Johnny Whitney’s vocals" while keeping it "fresh" with the use of synthesizers.